Opinion 
 Blogs 
 National Comment 
 Slutwalk may damage women's rights cause, professor says 

Slutwalk may damage women's rights cause, professor says

The slutwalk phenomenon does more harm to women than good, warns international anti-porn campaigner Gail Dines.

Professor Dines, a fierce critic of raunch culture who is touring Australia this month to promote her book Pornland, said that protest marches that aim to reclaim the word "slut" would only reinforce stereotypes.

"By having a slutwalk, you have turned the focus onto what women are wearing," Professor Dines said. "The men who are responding to this message are not getting the irony at all." By dressing in fishnets and push-up bras and brandishing 'slut" signs, she said, the organisers are playing into the hands of raunch culture. "Men want women to be sluts and now they're buying in."

The day before before Australia's first slutwalk sets off from the front steps of Melbourne's State Library on Saturday May 28, the professor will be speaking at the library's Wheeler Centre on the pressure young women feel to live up to the images available on internet porn.

"Young women today have two choices," she said, "to be f***able or invisible. If the only choice is to be hypersexual, you cannot call it a meaningful choice. In the US, even women who read the news, even politicians have to be [sexy]".

The dozens of slutwalk protests being organised in North America, Europe and Australia were inspired by a Canadian policeman's advice to college students that they should not "dress like sluts" if they didn't want to be sexually assaulted. In response, women have been marching to reclaim the word "slut" in the same way that gay rights activists have reclaimed the word "queer".

But the professor has been speaking out against the reclaiming campaign in The Guardian, on the BBC and in the Huffington Post. "'Slut' is an irredeemable word" she said, adding that as a Jewish woman, she had no desire to go on a "kike walk" — "some words come out of situations that are intolerable".

While slutwalk organisers believed they were empowering women by embracing the word "slut", Professor Dines said they were sending the wrong message to adolescent girls in a culture that takes its cues from pornography. "Do you think that a young women is going to be helped if she looks in the mirror and thinks the word 'slut'?"

Read more: http://www.smh.com.au/national/sl utwalk-may-damage-womens-rights-c ause-professor-says-20110513-1elq 5.html#ixzz1MCudHkoB

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size




comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
spot on!
Posted by luke, 13/05/2011 6:48:47 PM
I can't see any harm in it. Sexy doesn't mean "I want sex". Perhaps that message needs to be inculcated amongst the male community.
Posted by Sarcaustic Boo , 14/05/2011 12:02:36 AM
The normal interpretation of the word slut is a female with little or no self-respect. If that is how they want to portray themselves who are we to argue.
Posted by dbarrott, 14/05/2011 5:52:38 PM
The normal interpretation of the word slut is a female with little or no self-respect. If that is how they want to portray themselves who are we to argue.
Posted by dbarrott, 14/05/2011 5:52:39 PM
Women want to live up to internet porn? Riiiight.

Maybe the good professor should give up hijacking feminism to push her censorship agenda.

Posted by will_r, 15/05/2011 9:30:54 AM
I first read about this on the "spearhead", and yer pretty much saying the same thing.

excellent piece.

Posted by interesting, 15/05/2011 9:55:00 PM
So, here we have the denegration of women in a nutshell. Who want's to be equal to men? Not me! I want to be looked after and cared for instead. We are doing ourselves more harm than good with this rubbish of equalization. You can catch more flies with honey than vinegar, and I'm doing ok with my Honey. Respect has to be earned... not demanded or forced! Try it!
Posted by HollyMolly, 16/05/2011 10:10:28 PM
Well girls, you think like a slut, you are a slut. Sad, but why wonder why you're treated like one.

Wake up, be nice for a change, you get nothing by force. Certainly not respect or anything genuine.

We treat girls how we find them, and don't want a slut... thanks, but NO thanks. It's 'Almost' enough to make one gay, though not me.

This flaunting what you have leaves nothing to the imagination, your muffin tops are & boobs can look revolting, so try modesty, it's so nice for a change. Ohhh for modesty.

Posted by Max, 16/05/2011 10:19:53 PM
Thanks Max, I'm with Hollymolly, any muffin top or cleavage is for me and my husband. Yes, modesty first will give you respect. We must have gone to the same school.

Hope your lives are as good (modest & respectful) as mine.

Posted by Anniemee, 24/05/2011 1:39:37 AM
Professor Dines is in error.

It is not about women having just two choices, "to be f***able or invisible” it is to be able "to be f***able and visible" at the same time without being molested or in fear. Do we say to Man you have two choices "to be f***able or invisible”. Incredible logic where do they hand out these Professorships?

Who is to define what f***able actually is-Religion? We see the result of this each day with black shadows moving through the streets. We see it in action against a Woman journalist who was raped by 100 men in Egypt, Men who were supposedly demonstrating for Freedom - Free to do what?

Text is a powerful tool, words and phrases construct outcomes they are not benign. Man has owned the word Slut to woman’s detriment, by women owning the word - Men have to reflect on its use and similar words each time they wish to denigrate women to less, Other, to enable Man to excuse Mans terrible acts against women.

Posted by markjuliansmith, 1/06/2011 1:48:57 PM
1 | 2  |  next >
National Comment
Here is the place for you to vent on any national or world news and lifestyle stories on the YourGuide websites. If there is anything you see or hear that you like or don't like, tell us. Don't keep it to yourself!

Most popular articles




Hume Weekly







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...